Whether or not you agree with my father’s views on the Federal Income Tax, or the manner by which it is collected, it’s hard to condone the way he was treated by our government.

Death of a Patriot

by | Oct 19, 2015 | Taxation

My father Irwin A. Schiff was born Feb. 23rd 1928, the 8th child and only son of Jewish immigrants, who had crossed the Atlantic twenty years earlier in search of freedom. As a result of their hope and courage, my father was fortunate to have been born into the freest nation in the history of the world. But when he passed away on Oct. 16th, 2015 at the age of 87, a political prisoner of that same nation, legally blind and shackled to a hospital bed in a guarded room in intensive care, the free nation he was born into had itself died years earlier.

My father had a life-long love affair with our nation’s founding principals and proudly served his country during the Korean War, for a while even having the less than honorable distinction of being the lowest ranking American soldier in Europe. While in college he became exposed to the principles of Austrian economics through the writings of Henry Hazlitt and Frederick Hayek. He first became active in politics during Barry Goldwater’s failed 1964 presidential bid. His activism intensified during the Vietnam Era when he led local grass root efforts to resist Yale University’s plans to conduct aid shipments to North Vietnam at a time when that nation was actively fighting U.S. forces in the south. Later in life he staged an unsuccessful write-in campaign for governor of Connecticut, then eventually lost the Libertarian Party’s presidential nomination to Harry Brown in 1996.

In 1976 his beliefs in free market economics, limited government, and strict interpretation of the Constitution led him to write his first book The Biggest Con: How the Government is Fleecing You, a blistering indictment of the post New Deal expansion of government in the United States. The book achieved accolades in the mainstream conservative world, receiving a stellar review in the Wall Street Journal, among other mainstream publications.

But my father was most known for his staunch opposition to the Federal Income Tax, for which the Federal Government labeled him a “tax protester.” But he had no objection to lawful, reasonable taxation. He was not an anarchist and believed that the state had an important, but limited role to play in market based economy.  He opposed the Federal Government’s illegal and unconstitutional enforcement and collection of the income tax. His first book on this topic (he authored six books in total) How Anyone Can Stop Paying Income Taxes, published in 1982, became a New York Times best seller. His last, The Federal Mafia; How the Government Illegally Imposes and Unlawfully Collects Income Taxes, the first of three editions published in 1992, became the only non-fiction and second-to-last book to be banned in America. The only other book being Fanny Hill; Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure, banned for obscenity in 1821 and 1963.

His crusade to force the government to obey the law earned him three prison sentences, the final one being a fourteen-year sentence that he began serving ten years ago, at the age of 77. That sentence turned into a life sentence, as my father failed to survive until his planned 2017 release date. However, in actuality, the life sentence amounted to a death sentence. My father died from skin cancer that went undiagnosed and untreated while he was in federal custody. The skin cancer then led to a virulent outbreak of lung cancer that took his life just more than two months after his initial diagnosis.

The unnecessarily cruel twist in his final years occurred seven years ago when he reached his 80th birthday. At that point the government moved him from an extremely low security federal prison camp in New York State where he was within easy driving distance from family and friends, to a federal correctional institute, first in Indiana and then in Texas. This was done specially to give him access to better medical care. The trade off was that my father was forced to live isolated from those who loved him. Given that visiting him required long flights, car rentals, and hotel stays, his visits were few and far between. Yet while at these supposed superior medical facilities, my father received virtually no medical care at all, not even for the cataracts that left him legally blind, until the skin cancer on his head had spread to just about every organ in his body.

At the time of his diagnosis in early August of this year, he was given four to six months to live. We tried to get him out of prison on compassionate release so that he could live out the final months of his life with his family, spending some precious moments with the grandchildren he had barely known. But he did not live long enough for the bureaucratic process to be completed. Two months after the process began, despite the combined help of a sitting Democratic U.S. congresswoman and a Republican U.S. senator, his petition was still sitting on someone’s desk waiting for yet another signature, even though everyone at the prison actually wanted him released. Even as my father lay dying in intensive care, a phone call came in from a lawyer and the Bureau of Prisons in Washington asking the prison medical representatives for more proof of the serious nature of my father’s condition.

As the cancer consumed him, his voice changed and the prison phone system no longer recognized it, so he could not even talk with family members on the phone during his finale month of life. When his condition deteriorated to the point where he needed to be hospitalized, government employees blindly following orders that kept him shackled to his bed. This despite the fact that escape was impossible for an 87 year old terminally ill, legally blind patient who could barely breathe, let alone walk.

Whether or not you agree with my father’s views on the Federal Income Tax, or the manner by which it is collected, it’s hard to condone the way he was treated by our government. He held his convictions so sincerely and so passionately that he continued to espouse them until his dying breath. Like William Wallace in the final scene of Braveheart, an oppressive government may have succeeded in killing him, but they did not break his spirit. And that spirit will live on in his books, his videos, and in his children and grandchildren. Hopefully his legacy will one day help restore the lost freedoms he died trying to protect, finally allowing him to rest in peace.

Best Selling author Peter Schiff is the Chief Global Strategist of Euro Pacific Capital, a division of A.G.P. / Alliance Global Partners, a Registered Investment Advisor and a full-service broker/dealer. His podcasts are available on The Peter Schiff Channel on Youtube.

View all articles by author >

The views expressed represent those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the editors and publishers of Capitalism Magazine.

17 Comments

  1. I am sorry to read about your father’s passing. Your “eulogy” to him gave me goosebumps. I will make it a point to pick-up one of his books as I had in all honesty not heard of him. I hope that he did not die in vain. It is sad to see a once great nation succumb to confiscatory tax policies,political corruption, and crony capitalism.

  2. Irwin Schiff was a great man, a principled man. Extraordinarily hard to find these days. He was a political prisoner since he violated no actual federal laws. However, since federal judges are also paid by tax money, they did not let that technicality affect their decisions.

  3. I don’t agree with his legal cases but do agree that the Federal Govt is fleecing us.

    Is this the behavior of a government led by a wise Latina? By Justices who will not follow the laws, but their own private opinions? Is this compassionate conservatism? Irwin Schiff’s death was a searing indictment of Big Government.

  4. I’m sorry for your loss – this was a lovely and moving tribute to your father. I wonder if I still have my copy of “The Biggest Con.” I rather hope I do.

  5. Greetings from India… it is painful to read what happened to your father…it is even more depressing to realize what has happened to America.. book banning is truly not something that you would expect from a country where you can still get copies of Mein Kampf or any other communist drivel.. it is indeed shocking. I have come to expect the worst about the Federal Government and there fore have almost become numb to its barbaric nature… is any one surprised by how badly it has treated a prisoner of conscience.. this sounds more like a nightmarish situation from communist Russia… but it is int.. this actually happened in the land of the free… absolutely astounding
    R.I.P. Mr Schiff – thank you for standing up for liberty when it would have been far easier to fold.. reminds me of the last few lines of Ulysses – to strive, to seek and not to yield.

  6. *principles*

  7. I’m almost surprised that Irwin Schiff wasn’t classified as some sort of domestic terrorist…

  8. I would imagine that the exceedingly dangerous Islamists, who are not the least bit shy about communicating their intentions to kill as they are released from Guantanimo, were held in less strict confinement, certainly more humane.

  9. Thanks for writing this.

  10. If only your father’s courage was dispersed a bit more. We would be able to end the savagery that is the personal income tax. In moments. I am glad to hear he was a rebel to the end.

  11. While I am sorry your father ended his days in that manner, there’s a very old saying: “if you can’t do the time, don’t do the crime.”

    Your father was convicted in 2005 for filing multiple false tax returns, along with assisting others with false returns. He committed multiple felonies. I might have more respect for the theory of his position had he not claimed diminished capacity

    Schiff’s attorney had filed a brief claiming a diminished capacity defense, contending that Schiff had been diagnosed with a chronic, severe delusional disorder relating to his beliefs about the federal income tax system

    (from Wikipedia)

  12. Peter, I am very sorry to hear of your father’s passing. Very few people are principled enough to go to prison for something they believe in. This treatment is like something you would expect in China.

  13. Your family will be in my prayers. Keep up the family tradition and tilt those damn windmills until your last breath.

  14. Why would even take the time to bother commenting on this story? The epitome of low life.

  15. Well said, sir.

  16. Yes his attorney raised this issue, as he was not willing to raise the issues my father wanted to raise. It was interesting that the government hired the physiatrist who diagnosed my father as being delusional, yet refused to allow him to testify to that effect during his trial. That was clearly an error, as his codefendant’s conviction was reversed on the same issue. Had my father been an ordinary ax murder, his conviction would have been reversed too. But he was something far more dangerous, a man of principal who stood up against a corrupt government.

  17. P.S. My father was delusional, as he actually believed he could get justice on a tax issue in an American court. To believe that one truly has to be delusional.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

If you found this useful please share it.