In his Op-Ed column, “To arms,” Tony Blankley argues that the youth of America needs to be sacrificed for the greater good and hints that we may need the draft to do it. Referencing the last living veterans of this generation, Blankly writes: Just as the country that sent those 4.7 million young men off […]

The Draft Is Anathema To Human Freedom

by | Nov 22, 2003

In his Op-Ed column, “To arms,” Tony Blankley argues that the youth of America needs to be sacrificed for the greater good and hints that we may need the draft to do it. Referencing the last living veterans of this generation, Blankly writes:

Just as the country that sent those 4.7 million young men off to the Great War disrupted or ended those young lives for a larger purpose, today, the country that is America must decide whether it is prepared to disrupt or end young lives for another, greater, purpose. (As the father of two healthy teen-age sons, I think about such matters on a personal as well as theoretical basis.) But it is becoming ever more obvious that we do not have sufficient armed forces to face and master the many perils that are assembling against us. . .

. . . Finally, then — as it always does — it comes down to moral, not mathematical decisions. Unless the terrorists voluntarily go back into their hole (which seems unlikely), the president will soon have to ask the American people to accept our obligation to effectively fight the terrorist scourge by substantially increasing the size of our military. Whether by draft or by voluntary means, it will cost huge sums. Many of those new troops will fight — and some will die — so that millions of American civilians will not be killed by terrorists.

If the war against militant Islam is the preeminent crisis of our day, why call on the draft to fight it? Why frame the issue as question of whether America is willing to disrupt or end the lives of its young people?

If militant Islamists threaten our lives, freedom and prosperity, defending against them is not a sacrifice for the “greater good.” What good could be greater than defending one’s own life and happiness? Why does Tony Blankley ignore one’s selfish interest in defending one’s freedom?

Why? Because Mr. Blankley, like many conservatives, considers selflessness and not selfish interest to be the moral ideal. Even though America is a nation dedicated to protecting the life, liberty and happiness of the individual, conservatives are forever conflicted by the problem of the “greater good” and how best to sacrifice the inalienable rights of the individual to it.

Yet an individualist sacrifices to no one. He lives for himself, and to appeal to him, you must appeal to his values. To persuade young men and women to serve in the military, you need impress upon them the gravity of the threat today and the manner in which it impacts them. You need to convince them of the benefits of the martial lifestyle and pay them enough so that the cost of their time in service is not the derailment of every other aspect of their lives. Finally, you must keep the promise that if they are wounded or fall in battle, they and their loved ones will be cared for by a grateful nation.

Yes, America has a host of threats arrayed against it. We do not answer those threats by betraying our core values or sacrificing our freedom. The idea of the draft should be anathema to any person dedicated to human freedom. It takes men and women of substance to successfully defend the nation. Such men and women are not found by draft boards.

Nicholas Provenzo is founder and Chairman of the Center for the Advancement of Capitalism.

THE CAPITALIST ADVISOR

advertisement

NEW BOOK

America's Revolutionary Mind: A Moral History of the American Revolution and the Declaration That Defined It

The views expressed represent those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the editors and publishers of Capitalism Magazine.

Please keep all comments polite, civil, and on the topic of the article. Due to spam considerations, comments with links are put in a moderation queue and will not be visible to others.

 

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share this post with your friends!